Mr Khan’s accusation over the US$460m pre-contract cost was erroneous

I shared with Ms. Lisa Sachs, Director, Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment, USA, Dr. Jan Mangal former Petroleum Presidential Advisor, and Mr. Imran Khan of the Department of Public Information an Al Jazeera programme on Monday July 30. During the course of the half an hour discussion, responding to my assertion that ExxonMobil’s claim of US$460 million as per-contract cost to December 31, 2015 was inflated, Mr. Khan’s response was that my statement was unsubstantiated.

Immediately after the programme, Imran admitted to me on the telephone that he had not read my 44th Stabroek News Oil and Gas column published on May 24, 2018 which did exactly what he claimed I had not done. It is of course improper for Mr. Khan to make such an accusation to a domestic audience, let alone an international audience, whether out of ignorance or otherwise since no subsequent correction can undo the error.

In any case, I know and trust Mr. Khan to do the decent thing and to acknowledge his uninformed claim.

In our very cordial telephone conversation, I also drew Mr. Khan’s attention to column # 52 in the Oil and Gas series in which I produced a short table evidencing plagiarism in a statement issued by his Department. His response was that the plagiarism (my word) emanated from the Ministry of Finance and was merely repeated by his Department.

It would be good for Mr. Khan’s own professional reputation to avoid being a mouthpiece and acting more like a professional.

Every Man, Woman and Child in Guyana Must Become Oil-Minded (Part 52)

Introduction

I will resume the piece on Getting the work done next week to allow me in today’s column to address the outpouring of anger and hurt expressed by politicians, columnists, letter writers and contributors in the print and social media over an article in the New York Times one week ago. The title of the article was “The $20 billion Question for Guyana”.

The writer Clifford Krauss was considered by many as condescending and superficial and even those who saw his style as parody thought it was inappropriate relative to the seriousness of the topic. One Minister went so far as to call for the rejection of the article while one blogger suggested that Krauss should not be allowed back in Guyana. So much for freedom of expression and forward thinking in Guyana.

No one has so far been able to dispute the principal thrust of the article and I found it amusing that while some have questioned the figure of US$20 billion in oil revenues, an article by the Government’s Department of Public Information (DPI) cites the same figure in almost identical context. Continue reading “Every Man, Woman and Child in Guyana Must Become Oil-Minded (Part 52)”

Gov’t depriving Berbice Bridge Company and investors of rights under the law and concession agreement

A recent letter by Berbician Mr. Nowrang Persaud advocating for the Government to assume full ownership, control and management of the Berbice River Bridge appears to have aroused the disfavour of Minister of Public Security Mr. David Patterson and the Department of the Public Information. The Department quoted the Minister as assuring all Berbicians and users of the Bridge that the Government is not contemplating any increases to the Berbice Bridge Toll.

Minister Patterson seems to believe that it is that simple and simplistic. He must not only be familiar with the Provisions of the Berbice River Bridge Act but also the Concession Agreement dated June 26, 2006 under which the Bridge operates, and over which he exercises ministerial responsibility and has certain obligations to the Bridge Company and its investors.

The Concession Agreement was made under the laws of Guyana and obligates the Minister and the Government to grant periodic increases to tolls based on specific indications and circumstances as computed under Schedule 4 to the Concession Agreement. Continue reading “Gov’t depriving Berbice Bridge Company and investors of rights under the law and concession agreement”

Every Man, Woman and Child in Guyana Must Become Oil-Minded (Part 51)

Introduction

In the previous column in which I examined whether Guyana was prepared for First Oil in 2020, I wrote that the situation is not irretrievable but that “there need[ed] to be manpower changes and more leadership from the President.” I suggested that President Granger needed “to take charge before it is too late.”

As if on cue, the President was reported on the same day expressing a high level of confidence that “by the end of August or thereabouts the Guyanese people will see a Department of Energy with which they are satisfied”. This of course is not the first time that the President had set a timeline for the development of the sector and one recalls that very confidently on 11 April of this year the President had indicated that “by the first of May there will be some further announcement but right now the preparatory work is being done.”

Anyone familiar with management knows only too well of the consequences of deadlines and critical activities not met and the challenges which they later pose. At a talk I gave to an enthusiastic and engaged group of Guyanese in London last week, I identified some of the critical matters to be addressed and their current state.

Before engaging in elaborate details however, I think that a primary requirement is for the Government to formulate and articulate the objectives for the sector and hopefully to canvass views and comments on its preferred model. That exercise does not appear to have commenced.

Thereafter, some detailed and sometimes tedious work will have to be undertaken. Here are some of these. Continue reading “Every Man, Woman and Child in Guyana Must Become Oil-Minded (Part 51)”

Every Man, Woman and Child in Guyana Must Become Oil-Minded (Part 50)

Introduction

Inspired by the May 20, 2015 announcement by ExxonMobil that it had made the largest discovery of petroleum resources for that year off the coast of Guyana, this column with the title Road to First Oil began, coincidentally, on May 26, 2017 and was expected to run for approximately twenty-five weeks. In fact, today’s column is the 50th in the series and there seems to be no reason why the Daily Editor would not wish to continue it indefinitely, albeit with a change in the contributor at some future date.

If for no other reason, the media and civil society need to guard against the seemingly single-minded pursuit of an oil economy to the exclusion of what President Granger has dubbed the six curses of Guyana – sugar, rice, bauxite, gold, diamonds, and timber – the essence of the Dutch Disease. In fact, there is little evidence of any conscious effort by the Government in the past three years to prevent the Dutch Disease from afflicting the country.

The purpose of today’s column is to assess the progress and preparation Guyana has made to being a petro-state following the first announcement made more than three years ago. The declared reserves at that stage of approximately eight hundred thousand barrels of oil has now jumped to at least four times that number. This is huge and puts Guyana among the world’s top oil producing countries measured by reserves per capita of population. But when it comes to petroleum, to use the language of Portia in Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice, Guyana seems to be twice blessed – as volume increased so has the price for crude oil which has increased by approximately 40% in the last three years. Continue reading “Every Man, Woman and Child in Guyana Must Become Oil-Minded (Part 50)”